I'm from South Jersey, Cape May, and yes, the Jersey Devil was feared by all. But I lived near a beach called Higbee's Beach, and there was always talk about a red eyed monster there. Some said it was the spawn of Mother Leeds and the Devil (aka the Jersey Devil), others think it was a barnacle encrusted pirate.
I now live on Virginia's Eastern Shore, and here we have the Trollick. Looks like a monkey. Some have described it with long red hair, others describe it as snow white. We also have the black cat, thought to be a huge feral cat, or some say, a panther. That is, in fact, true to a point. There was actually a huge black cat that attacked a woman in Chincoteague just a couple years ago. But how big is big?
There is also a nature trail nearby, that many people run their golf carts down to get to a little private beach. More often than not, the electrical systems fail on this trail for a while, and people are stuck until mysteriously the batteries start functioning again. It only happens with electric carts--Gators, and gas powered carts get through just fine. A ghost hunting group came to check out the trail, but couldn't find anything. Of course, though, they were on foot. LOL